Please read the previous blog before reading this one!
Ice Nine Kills Discography Ranking
I will only be ranking their full-length efforts, excluding the likes of 'The Burning,' 'The Pop-Punk Ska Years,' 'The Predator,' and any acoustic songs the band has released.
#5 - Last Chance to Make Amends
At the bottom of the list is 2006's 'Last Chance to Make Amends.' I've listened to this bad Larry once, and I don't remember any of it. I know a song from this album made it onto 'The Burning,' but that's about it. This album is more post-hardcore, with a bunch of soaring melodies. In my opinion, the band didn't do this style too well. The album is still pretty good, but a lot of the melodies blend together, and they're not very strong. I don't have much more to say about this one.
Favorite Song: N/A
#4 - Safe is Just a Shadow
|
2017 re-recording artwork |
I think part of the reason this one is so low is just because I don't know it as well as the ones I've ranked higher on this list. This album had a re-recording released in early 2017, which is the version I am more familiar with. This album saw the band's songwriting strength increase drastically from their previous efforts. With added vocal hooks, mind-blowing guitar riffs, and an obvious increase in production value, the band took a massive step in the right direction. The album's opener 'Proximity Mines in the Complex' smacks the listener right across the face with an assault of sounds. The song's opening tapping guitar riff gives the listener a feel of the atmosphere the album is going for - ominous, but relevant within the culture of post-hardcore and melodic metalcore fans. This album contains fast songs with stuttering riffs, dangerous china cymbal hits, and massive dual screams from lead vocalist Spencer Charnas and backup vocalist Justin DeBlieck. The album takes the listener through a journey, with highlight tracks such as 'The People Under the Stairs' and 'The Greatest Story Ever Told,' as well as deep cuts such as 'Red Sky Warning.' Though the album was great for the band, and I do like it quite a bit, a few of the songs fell flat for me. I couldn't tell you what any part of a song like 'So This is My Future' sounds like. Definitely worth a listen, but there is a little bit of filler material here.
Favorite Song: Proximity Mines in the Complex
#3 - Every Trick in the Book
I feel disgusting putting this one at number three. We're into territory of albums I like a lot, now. Front to back, this album captures the storybook atmosphere it was going for. Right off the bat, you can feel yourself immersed in the sound of 'The Nature of the Beast,' based on George Orwell's 'Animal Farm.' Blasting you off from there, the album does not slow down until the semi-ballad 'Star-Crossed Enemies,' based on Romeo and Juliet. Constantly bombarding the listener, Every Trick in the Book has new tricks (no pun intended) hidden around every corner. This is the album that got me into the band, and this album cycle is the first time I saw them. That was way back in early 2016. If it wasn't for the songs 'The Plot Sickens' and 'Alice' I would've ranked this album higher. Something about those songs - I don't know. They just feel super weak and cliched to me. I think the only "deep cut" song on this album, 'The People in the Attic,' deserves some more recognition. The chorus in that one gets me every time. 'Me, Myself & Hyde' has to be my favorite song by this band, though. The breakdown, the chorus, the intro. Oh man, everything about that one is just so good.
Favorite song: Me, Myself & Hyde
#2 - The Silver Scream
|
2019 deluxe edition artwork |
So, I actually rank band discographies over on my Twitter account. I listen to a lot of music. I put this album at number one, and I'm here to tell you why I've changed my decision. The band's 2018 effort is super strong. When it released, I listened to it on repeat for the whole weekend. Within a matter of two days, I'd listened to it at least six times. I can tell you right now, I hate the song 'Savages.' I hate it. So much. The song itself is technically decent, and it's based on The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, a movie I enjoy. The band keeps pushing the song for radio play, and they play it at every show now. It was widely recognized by fans as the worst song on the album, so I have no idea why they took this route.
In turn, this album contains incredible songwriting on just about every other song, save for 'Freak Flag,' but I'm okay with that song. Every song perfectly captures the sound of the movie it was based on. A good example of this can be found in 'Stabbing in the Dark,' a song based on John Carpenter's 'Halloween.' The song starts off with a clock ticking, signifying the presence of Dr. Loomis. Later in the song, panic chords that gives listeners the feeling they are being attacked by Michael Myers. Oddly enough, I find these panic chords very similar to the strikes of the piano that was made popular by 'Psycho.' Though, these chill-inducing staccatos can be found in the soundtrack to 1978's 'Halloween' in the song 'The Shape Lurks,' a song that plays when tension between Michael Myers and his victim arises. This track can particularly be found near the climax of the film, when Michael is actively pursuing Laurie Strode. Ice Nine Kills capture the intensity of this sequence perfectly in their song.
This album feels like a journey, and it's always pleasing to listen to. I feel fully immersed in the album with every listen, and it fascinates me how they could write songs that capture the source material so well. Huge props to the band on this one. If it wasn't for 'Savages' or 'Freak Flag' though, this would probably be my top pick.
Favorite song: Stabbing in the Dark
#1 - The Predator Becomes the Prey
Every song on this one. Every. Single. One. Banger. I find myself coming back to this album more than any of their other albums. The production is clean. The songwriting is on point. The vocals are terrifying, and at the same time, they're beautiful. The guys really hit the nail on the head with this one, or should I say.. the hatchet? 'Let's Bury the Hatchet...In Your Head' is a song that really captures what this album is about - high energy, heavy music, and songs to get people moving. This one, along with 'The Coffin is Moving' and 'The Fastest Way to a Girl's Heart is Through Her Ribcage,' captures what I like about the album. The hooks on this album are phenomenal. These songs get stuck in my head a lot.
This album has a lot of deep cuts, too, as opposed to the newest two albums. 'The Product of Hate' was one of the first songs by this band that I added to my playlist. My brother used to play this band a lot in the car and at my house before I got into them, and the songs he would play a lot were from this album, since it was their newest release at the time. 'The Product of Hate' was actually one of the songs I recognized while going through the songs on my own time, and I added it to my playlist. I think it's interesting that, with a genre of music like this, they can write a song about the Boston Marathon bombing - what the song is about - and speak how they feel about it.
Another song I wanted to shine some light on is 'My Life in Two.' Beautiful vocals in this song. This one has, in my opinion, Spencer's best vocal effort in their whole discography. The lyrics in the chorus, paired with the melody that brings them to life, get me every time. Just give this one a listen. It's not too long.
This album feels like it flies by when I listen to it. Not literally, but you get what I mean. One second I'ts starting. Next thing I know, it's ending. Lots of fun listening to this one, and I still put it on a bunch.
Favorite Song: My Life in Two
If you read this blog and the last one, thank you for reading. I hope you check out this awesome band! Show them your support. They deserve it.